Chicago Food Guide: Deep Dish, Italian Beef and the Ketchup Rule

Chicago Food Guide Deep Dish, Italian Beef and the Ketchup Rule

Chicago has three signature foods and visitors reliably order the wrong one. Deep dish pizza is what the city is famous for; thin, crisp tavern-style cut into squares is what most Chicagoans actually eat most weeks. Both are worth having, and knowing the difference marks you out immediately.

The hot dog rule is not a joke either. Ketchup is genuinely, seriously not put on a Chicago hot dog.

Illinois
Book Your Trip With Extra Discount
Get Extra Discount For Your Next Trip

The quick answer

Deep dish takes around 45 minutes to bake. Order it when you sit down.

Tavern-style thin crust, cut into squares, is what locals eat more often.

Italian beef is the city’s best sandwich: thin roast beef, gravy, giardiniera.

Dipped means the whole sandwich is submerged in the beef juice before serving.

A Chicago hot dog has seven toppings and never ketchup.

Garrett popcorn in the caramel and cheese mix is the local souvenir food.

The West Loop holds the ambitious modern restaurants.

Pizza and beef

Deep dish is baked in a round steel pan with a buttery crust pressed up the sides, cheese on the bottom, fillings in the middle and chunky tomato sauce on top, because a 45 minute bake would burn the cheese otherwise. It is closer to a pie than to pizza. Pizzeria Uno claims the 1943 invention, Lou Malnati’s is the local favourite and Giordano’s makes the stuffed version with a second layer of dough. It takes around 45 minutes, so order it the moment you sit down.

Tavern-style is the pizza Chicago actually eats: very thin, crisp to the edge, cut into squares rather than wedges, designed for eating in bars alongside beer. Vito and Nick’s is the classic. It receives almost no attention outside the city and locals will tell you it is the real Chicago pizza.

Italian beef is thinly sliced roast beef simmered in its own seasoned juice, piled into a French roll and topped with either sweet peppers or hot giardiniera, a chopped pickled vegetable relish in oil. Ask for it dipped and the whole sandwich is briefly submerged in the juice, which requires the stance: lean forward, elbows out, feet apart. Al’s Beef, Johnnie’s and Portillo’s are the names.

The Bear has driven a substantial rise in Italian beef interest since 2022, and queues at several places reflect it.

Hot dogs and the rest

A Chicago-style hot dog is an all-beef frankfurter in a poppy seed bun with yellow mustard, chopped white onion, bright green sweet pickle relish, a dill pickle spear, tomato slices, pickled sport peppers and a dusting of celery salt. That is called dragged through the garden.

Ketchup is not an option. Some places do not stock it, several will refuse, and the objection is genuine rather than performed. Portillo’s, Superdawg and Gene and Jude’s, which serves a stripped-back version with fries on top, are the classics.

Garrett Popcorn sells the Chicago Mix, caramel and cheese popcorn together in one bag, which sounds wrong and is not.

Malört is a bitter wormwood liqueur made in Chicago and drunk almost entirely as a dare. Every bar has it. The facial expression it produces is a local sport.

Jibarito is a Puerto Rican sandwich invented in Humboldt Park using flattened fried plantains instead of bread.

The West Loop and Fulton Market hold the ambitious restaurants, in converted meatpacking buildings.

Pilsen has the best Mexican food, and the city has one of the largest Mexican populations in the country.

Devon Avenue in the north is the South Asian corridor.

Prices: a deep dish for two is $30 to $40, an Italian beef $9 to $13, a hot dog $5 to $8, and West Loop dinners $50 to $100 a head.

Frequently asked questions

Is deep dish really what Chicagoans eat?

Not usually. Tavern-style thin crust, cut into squares and eaten in bars, is far more common in everyday life. Deep dish is genuinely good and worth having once, and most locals treat it as something you do when visitors are in town.

Why does deep dish take so long?

Because it bakes for around 45 minutes in a deep steel pan, which is also why the sauce goes on top: cheese exposed for that long would burn. Order it as soon as you sit down, or ring ahead, since many places take advance orders.

What is an Italian beef?

Thinly sliced roast beef simmered in seasoned juice, served in a French roll with sweet peppers or hot giardiniera. Ordering it dipped means the whole sandwich is submerged in the juice before it is handed over, which requires eating it leaning forward with elbows out.

Can you put ketchup on a Chicago hot dog?

You can ask. Some places do not stock it and some will decline. The objection is genuine rather than a running joke, and it concerns the balance of the seven traditional toppings. Mustard, relish, onion, tomato, pickle, sport peppers and celery salt is the standard.

What is tavern-style pizza?

Very thin, crisp-edged pizza cut into squares rather than wedges, made for eating in bars alongside beer. It is the pizza Chicago eats most often, receives almost no national attention, and Vito and Nick’s on the south side is the benchmark.

What is Malört?

A bitter wormwood liqueur made in Chicago and drunk almost entirely as a dare or an initiation. It is not pleasant and is not meant to be. Every bar in the city stocks it and watching a first-timer’s face is a local pastime.

Where do locals eat in Chicago?

Tavern-style pizza in neighbourhood bars, Italian beef from corner stands rather than the famous chains, Pilsen for Mexican food, Devon Avenue for South Asian, and the West Loop for a night out. The tourist strip on Michigan Avenue is not where the food is.

Has The Bear changed Chicago’s food scene?

It has substantially raised interest in Italian beef since 2022, with visible queues at several long-established stands and a general uptick in visitors seeking the sandwich. The restaurants themselves were already there; what changed is how many people know about them.

How much does eating out cost in Chicago?

An Italian beef is $9 to $13, a hot dog $5 to $8, a deep dish for two $30 to $40, and dinner in the West Loop $50 to $100 a head. Chicago eats well at both ends and the cheap end is where the identity is.

Our Illinois travel guide covers the state, the Chicago guide covers what to see, and where to stay puts you near the right neighbourhoods.

Illinois
Book Your Trip With Extra Discount
Get Extra Discount For Your Next Trip
Scroll to Top